It's either too hot or too cold. You're always fearful, always worried, and always hungry. You're packed in with thousands of people. You're alone. There is nothing to do but wait. There is nothing to do today and there won't be anything to do tomorrow.
And there is no escape.
These experiences are shared by people around the world: in the refugee camps of the Darfur region of Sudan, in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and in Rwanda. In Syria, in Chechnya, and in Somalia.
This is not make-believe, and more importantly, it is impossible to experience without actually living a refugee's life and thinking a refugee's thoughts.
Yet, from the 4th to the 8th of October, the well-renowned group Doctors without Borders decided to give Nashville residents a look inside a refugee camp. This "experience" was billed as an opportunity for comfortable American citizens to view what it would be like to live in absolute squalor and how Doctors without Borders was helping.
Holly Johnson, director of Refugee and Immigration Services for Catholic Charities of Tennessee, spoke positively about the event: "I think people, myself included, really have no idea what life is like for refugees, and this will give us a more complete picture."
No, it won't.
While their intentions were likely solid, "experiences" like this only serve to belittle the very cause which these groups seek to promote. While these events spread needed information, their "mock" style is almost ride-like. It's neat, compact, exciting, and fits into your day without causing too much trouble. You get your ticket, buckle in, "aware" yourself for 30 minutes to (gasp) and hour or so, and then you go about your day.
The key missing factor is that, while one sees the tents and eats the prepared meals, the experience lacks the time and mental factors which are at the heart of a refugee's peril. A refugee never knows when he or she will get to leave the camp or even eat, for that matter. They are always fearful and don't simply get to go back to the car when they are tired of the "experience."
In similar fashion to Habitat for Humanity's sleep-outs on Alumni Lawn, where students pretend to be homeless by watching a movie and making S'mores outside, and even the National Holocaust Memorial Museum (which has managed to turn one of the greatest human tragedies into a two-hour simulation-ride), this event only trivializes real events and real suffering by catering to the shallow need of many Americans to only support causes which they can feel and touch.
A refugee camp cannot be understood like static electricity at an interactive science museum. It involves the very essence of what humans on this planet must go through to survive another day. Raising money and awareness through films, photos, pamphlets, and other means is critical and necessary, but this sort of self-serving "pretend" is far from it.


Most people don't have time
Most people don't have time to go travel to Somalia in order to visit a real refugee camp. At least when you do the doctors without borders tour you learn about what they are and what happens to the people and how they try to help people in the refugee camps. True, you aren't a refugee. But at least people now know what a refugee is. I found the hour+ long tour quite educational and eye opening to say the least. And if the tour lasted for any longer than that, then most people probably wouldn't do it at all and would remain COMPLETELY ignorant of refugee camps. Some knowledge is better than none. I recommend you try before you judge.
I really agree with you
I really agree with you about this- I find the mock refugee camps to be incredibly offensive.
[delete]
[delete]
Delete?
Delete?